Suggested answers for case study 9


Jaccard and Dice coefficients

The most similar associations are the Stricklandia and Eocoelia communities. Trends are difficult to see from the table.

Cluster analysis of taxa

The Lingula community (black) form a well-defined group, and the Clorinda community (green) also shows up well except for the exclusion of Eoplectodonta. The other taxa seem to be spread across communities.

Detrended correspondence analysis of associations

The order of the associations along the first ordination axis is Lingula, Eocoelia, Pentamerus, Stricklandia and Clorinda, in perfect agreement with the onshore-offshore ordering.

Seriation

The seriation method also gives the 'correct' ordering of samples.

Cluster analysis of associations

The cluster analysis is in good agreement with the results above. Remember that the PENTA-STRIC and EOCOE-LINGU pairs in the dendrogram are arbitrarily oriented, so they can be reordered to appear in the expected sequence.

To conclude, the environmental gradient is well supported by several different analysis methods.