TABLE 1. All taxa/morphotypes reported from the Bovay and Bolden localities in northern Mississippi, and the Warman locality in western Tennessee, USA (Wang et al., 2013). The table also lists each taxon/morphotype’s organ type, proposed modern affinity, and its figure numbers in this paper and in Wang et al. (2013). “+” indicates a taxon/morphotype is present at a locality.
Proposed modern affinity | Taxa/morphotypes | Figure numbers in this paper | Figure numbers in Wang et al. (2013) | Organ type | Warman | Bovay | Bolden |
Lauraceae | Lauroflorum warmanensis Wang, Blanchard, and Dilcher, 2013 | figure 3 | flower | + | |||
Annonaceae | Anonaspermum robertsi (Berry) Wang, Blanchard, and Dilcher, 2013 | Figure 4 | figure 4.1-3, 4.5-8 | seed | + | + | |
Anonaspermum warmanensis Wang, Blanchard, and Dilcher, 2013 | figure 4.4 | seed | + | ||||
Magnoliaceae | cf. Magnolia sp. | figure 5 | seed | + | |||
Araceae | cf. Acorites heeri Crepet, 1978 | figure 6 | inflorescence | + | |||
Altingiaceae | Claiborne Altingiaceae Infructescence Type 1 | figure 7 | infructescence | + | |||
Hamamelidaceae | Corylopsis grotei Wang, Blanchard, and Dilcher, 2013 | figure 8 | seed | + | |||
Hamamelis sp. | figure 9 | seed | + | ||||
Euphorbiaceae | Hippomaneoidea warmanensis Crepet and Daghlian, 1982 | figure 20 | inflorescence | + | |||
Malpighiaceae | Eoglandulosa warmanensis Taylor and Crepet, 1987 | figure 21 | flower | + | |||
Salicaceae | cf. Populus sp. | Figure 13 | fruit | + | |||
Fabaceae | Caesalpinia claibornensis Herendeen and Dilcher, 1991 | figure 13.4-5 | fruit | + | |||
Crudia grahamiana Herendeen and Dilcher, 1990a | figure 13.6 | fruit | + | ||||
Diplotropis claibornensis Herendeen and Dilcher, 1990b | figure 14.1 | fruit | + | ||||
Eliasofructus claibornensis Herendeen and Dilcher, 1990c | figure 14.2 | fruit | + | ||||
Eomimosoidea plumosa Crepet and Dilcher, 1977 | figures 10-11 | inflorescence | + | ||||
Ormosia sp. | figure 14.5-6 | fruit | + | ||||
Protomimosoidea buchananensis Crepet and Taylor, 1986 | Figures 5-7 | figure 12 | flower | + | + | ||
Swartzia sp. | figure 13.1 | fruit | + | ||||
cf. Acrocarpus sp. | Figure 8 | fruit | + | ||||
cf. Erythrophleum sp. | figure 13.2 | fruit | + | ||||
cf. Gleditsia? mississippiensis (Berry) Berry, 1930 | Figure 9 | figure 14.3 | fruit | + | + | ||
cf. Leguminosites phyllocarpoides Berry, 1930 | figure 13.3 | fruit | + | ||||
Claiborne Fabaceae Floral Type 1 | Figure 11 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Fabaceae Floral Type 2 | Figure 12 | flower | + | + | |||
"Short, broad winged fruit" | Figure 10 | fruit | + | + | |||
"Thick walled fruit" | figure 14.4 | fruit | + | ||||
Fagaceae | Quercus oligocenensis Daghlian and Crepet, 1983 | figure 15 | staminate inflorescences | + | |||
cf. Trigonobalanoidea americana Crepet and Nixon, 1989 | Figure 14 | infructescence | + | ||||
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 1 | figure 16.1-2 | fruits | + | ||||
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 2 | figure 16.3 | fruit | + | ||||
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 3 | Figure 15.1-3 | figure 17.4 | fruit | + | |||
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 4 | Figure 16 | fruit | + | ||||
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 5 | Figure 15.5 | figure 17.1-3 | fruit | + | |||
Juglandaceae | Eokachyra aeolius Crepet, Dilcher and Potter, 1975 | figure 18 | inflorescence | + | |||
Paleooreomunnea stoneana Dilcher, Potter and Crepet, 1976 | figure 19 | fruit | + | ||||
Moraceae | Cornerocarpon copiosum Grote, 1989 | figures 22, 23 | fruit | + | |||
Rhamnaceae | “Solanites” pusillus Berry, 1930 | Figures 17-18 | figure 35 | flower | + | + | + |
Sapindaceae | Bridgesia bovayensis Manchester and O’Leary, 2010 | Figure 19 | fruit | + | |||
Theaceae | Andrewsiocarpon henryense Grote and Dilcher, 1989 | figure 27 | fruit | + | |||
Gordonia warmanensis Grote and Dilcher, 1989 | Figure 20 | figure 24 | fruit | + | + | ||
cf. Gordonia sp. 1 | figure 25 | flower | + | ||||
cf. Gordonia sp. 2 | figure 26 | flower | + | ||||
Icacinaceae | cf. Natsiatum wilcoxiana (Berry) Stull, Moore and Manchester, 2011 | Figure 21 | endocarp | + | |||
Eucommiaceae | Eucommia eocenica (Berry) Brown, 1940 | Figure 22 | fruit | + | + | ||
Bignoniaceae | Grotea warmanensis Wang, Blanchard and Dilcher, 2013 | figure 28.1 | fruit | + | |||
Oleaceae | Fraxinus wilcoxiana (Berry) Call and Dilcher, 1992 | figure 29 | fruit | + | |||
Caprifoliaceae | Dipelta bovayensis sp. nov. | Figure 23 | fruit | + | |||
Araliaceae | “Aralia” semina Berry, 1930 | figure 30 | seed | + | |||
Paleopanax boldensis sp. nov. | Figure 24 | fruit | + | ||||
Angiosperm incertae sedis - flowers | Antholithes wilcoxensis Berry, 1930 | figure 34 | flower | + | |||
“Solanites” sarachaformis Berry, 1930 | Figure 26 | flower | + | ||||
cf. “Solanites” saportanus (Berry) Martínez-Millán, 2010 | Figure 25 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 1 | figure 36.1-2 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 2 | figure 36.3-4 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 3 | figure 37 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 4 | figure 38 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 5 | Figure 27 | figure 39 | flower | + | + | ||
Claiborne Floral Type 6 | figure 40 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 7 | Figure 28 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 8 | Figure 29 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 9 | Figure 30 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 10 | Figure 31 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 11 | Figure 32 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 12 | Figure 33 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 13 | Figure 34 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 14 | Figure 35 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 15 | Figure 36 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 16 | Figure 37 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 17 | Figure 38 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 18 | Figure 39 | flower | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 19 | Figure 40 | petal? | + | ||||
Claiborne Floral Type 20 | Figure 41 | stamens | + | ||||
Angiosperm incertae sedis - infructescences | " Sparganium " sp. | Figure 42 | figure 49 | infructescence | + | + | |
Claiborne Infructescence Type 1 | figure 31 | infructescence | + | ||||
Claiborne Infructescence Type 2 | figure 32 | infructescence | + | ||||
Claiborne Infructescence Type 3 | figure 33 | infructescence | + | ||||
Claiborne Infructescence Type 4 | Figure 43 | infructescence | + | ||||
Claiborne Infructescence Type 5 | Figure 44 | infructescence | + | ||||
Claiborne Infructescence Type 6 | Figure 45 | infructescence | + | ||||
Claiborne Infructescence Type 7 | Figure 46 | infructescence | + | ||||
Angiosperm incertae sedis - fruits and seeds | Carpolithus boldensis sp. nov. | Figure 47 | seed | + | |||
Carpolithus collinsi (Berry) Wang, Blanchard, and Dilcher, 2013 | figure 41 | fruit | + | ||||
Carpolithus complanata (Lesquereux) Wang, Blanchard, and Dilcher, 2013 | figure 42 | seed | + | ||||
Carpolithus prangosoides Berry, 1916b | figure 43 | fruit | + | ||||
Carpolithus sophorites Berry, 1916b | figure 44 | seed | + | ||||
Carpolithus warmanensis Wang, Blanchard, and Dilcher, 2013 | figure 45 | fruit | + | ||||
Palmocarpon wilcoxiana (Berry) Wang, Blanchard, Dilcher, 2013 | Figure 55 | figure 47, 48 | fruit | + | + | ||
“Acer” knowltoni (Berry) Brown, 1940 | Figure 49 | fruit | + | + | |||
“Copaifera” yeguana Berry, 1915 | figure 46 | fruit | + | ||||
cf. Saportaspermum sp. | Figure 48 | seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 1 | figure 50 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 2 | figure 51 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 3 | figure 52 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 4 | figure 53 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 5 | figure 54 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 6 | Figure 50 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 7 | Figure 51 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 8 | Figure 52 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 9 | Figure 53 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Claiborne Fruit/Seed Type 10 | Figure 54 | fruit/seed | + | ||||
Plant incertae sedis | Equisetum? | figure 55 | unknown | + | |||
Undetermined | Claiborne Undetermined Structure 1 | Figure 56 | unknown | + | |||
Claiborne Undetermined Structure 2 | Figure 57 | unknown | + | ||||
Claiborne Undetermined Structure 3 | Figure 58 | unknown | + | ||||
Claiborne Undetermined Structure 4 | Figure 59 | unknown | + | ||||
Number of taxa/morphotypes from each locality | 62 | 43 | 14 | ||||
Number of taxa/morphotypes from all three localities | 106 |
TABLE 2. Comparison of major characters of Protomimosoidea buchananensis, Claiborne Fabaceae Floral Types 1 and 2, Claiborne Floral Types 17 and 18. All dimensions are in millimeters. “?” indicates that a measurement is not available or a character is not observed.
Ovary size (length x width) | Number of stamens | Filament length | Anther size (length x width) |
Anther connective | Perianth (length x width) |
Pedicel (length x width) |
|
Protomimosoidea buchananensis | 2 x 1 | 10 | 5 | 0.75-1 x 0.5 | strong | 2 x 1 | up to 6 x 0.3 |
Claiborne Fabaceae Floral Type 1 | expanded | ? | 9 | 1.5 x? | ? | ? | ? |
Claiborne Fabaceae Floral Type 2 | 2 x 2.5 | > 10 | 1 | 0.5 x 0.5 | strong | 1 x 1 | 5-5.5 x 1 |
Claiborne Floral Type 17 | 2 x 2.5 | > 10 | 4-5 | ? | ? | 4 x 2 | 3.5 x 1 |
Claiborne Floral Type 18 | 2 x 2 | 4-6 | 2, fused | 0.5-1 x 0.5 | very strong | ? | 1 x 0.5 |
TABLE 3. Major characters of Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Types 1 to 5 and Catahoulea grahamii. All dimensions are in millimeters. “?” indicates that a measurement is not available or a character is not observed.
Fruit size (length x width) | Number of nutlets | Nutlet size (length x width) | Spines | Cupule valve | Web-like pattern of cupule | Peduncle (length x width) | Specimen number and references | |
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 1 | 15 x 35 | ? | ? | simple or branched | ? | ? | 10 x 1 | UF15826-51476 (figure 16.1-2 in Wang et al., 2013) and six other specimens from Warman clay pit, Tennessee |
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 2 | 20 x 20 | ? | ? | simple | ? | no | ? | UF15826-51231 (figure 16.3 in Wang et al., 2013) |
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 3 | 10 x 10 | at least 2 | 2 x 1 | simple or branched | 3 | yes | 0.5-1 x? | UF15815-005347 (Figure 15.1-2); UF15826-029215 (figure 2.F in DeVore et al., 2014); UF15826-51307 (Figure 15.3; figure 17.4 in Wang et al., 2013; figure 2.C DeVore et al., 2014). |
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 4 | 12 x 6.5 | at least 2 | 7 x 5 | branched | ? | spines intertwined | 2 x 0.5 | UF15737-59211 (Figure 16) |
Claiborne Fagaceae Fruit Type 5 | 25 in diameter | ? | ? | branched | 3 | yes | 10 x 1 | UF15826-29216 (Figure 15.5; figure 17.1-3 in Wang et al., 2013) |
Catahoulea grahamii | 5.5-10 x 13 | 3 | one large, 3 x 2; two small 3 x 1 | simple or branched | 3 | yes | 9.5 x 0.3 | UF 15841-062191 (Figure 15.4) and other 23 specimens from Huntsville, Texas (DeVore et al., 2014) |
TABLE 4. Comparison of characters of Claiborne Floral Type 5, Claiborne Floral Types 8 to 11, " Diospyros " mirafloriana, Eoglandulosa warmanensis, “Solanites” pusillus, “Solanites” saportanus, and “Solanites” sarachaformis. All dimensions are in millimeters. “?” indicates that a measurement is not available or a character is not observed.
Taxa/morphotypes | Flower -merous | Size in diameter when vertically compressed | Number of sepals | Sepal base | Sepal shape | Sepal size (length x width) | Sepal venation | Number of petals | Petal shape | Petal size (length x width) |
Claiborne Floral Type 5 | 5-merous | 22 | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
Claiborne Floral Type 8 | ?4-merous | 8 | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
Claiborne Floral Type 9 | 5-merous | 6 | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
Claiborne Floral Type 10 | 6-merous | 15 | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | 6 | ovate | 5 x 2-2.5 |
Claiborne Floral Type 11 | ?4-merous | 11 | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
"Diospyros" mirafloriana | 5-merous | 35-40 | 5 | separate | ? | 12.5 x 9.5 | ? | ? | ? | ? |
Eoglandulosa warmanensis (Wang et al. 2013) | 5-merous | 10 | ?5 | connate | oblong to triangular | 4 x 2 | ? | ? | ? | ? |
“Solanites” pusillus | 5-merous | 8-10 | 5 | separate | isosceles-triangular | 2.5-3 x 2.5-3 | mid-vein present | 5 | ? | 3 x 1-2 |
“Solanites” saportanus | 6-merous | 9 | 6 | separate | triangular | 3 x 2 | mid-vein present | ? | ? | ? |
“Solanites” sarachaformis | 4-merous | 10 | 4 | separate | ovate | 4.5 x 3.5 | 5 veins | ? | ? | ? |
TABLE 4 (continued).
Taxa/morphotypes | Petal venation | Arrangement | Number of periath parts when sepals and petals can not be distinguished | Perianth part shape | Perianth part size (length x width) | Perianth part venation | Hypanthium | Hypanthium rim | Floral cup diameter | Ovary | Pedicel (length x width) |
Claiborne Floral Type 5 | ? | ? | 5 | ovate | 7 x 5 | faint veins | present | ? | ? | superior | ? |
Claiborne Floral Type 8 | ? | alternate, 2 whorls | 8 | triangular | 1.5 -2.5 x 1.5-2 | 5 veins | present | present | 3 | superior | ? x 0.5 |
Claiborne Floral Type 9 | ? | ? | 5 | triangular | 2 x 1 | not observed | present | present | ? | 2-3 | ? x 0.2 |
Claiborne Floral Type 10 | thin | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | inferior | ? |
Claiborne Floral Type 11 | ? | ? | ? | ovate | 5 x 3 | fine veins | ? | ? | ? | ? | long; 10 x 0.5 |
"Diospyros" mirafloriana | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | present | present | 12.5 | ? | ? |
Eoglandulosa warmanensis (Wang et al. 2013) | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
“Solanites” pusillus | ? | alternate, two whorls | ? | ? | ? | ? | present | present | 3.5 – 4.5 | inferior | 1 x 0.5 |
“Solanites” saportanus | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | present | absent | 4 | ? | ? x 0.5 |
“Solanites” sarachaformis | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | present | absent | ? | ? | ? |
TABLE 5. Total numbers of specimens, leaves, and reproductive material from the Bovay and Bolden clay pit, Mississippi, and the Warman clay pit, Tennessee.
Bovay | Bolden | Bovay and Bolden | Warman | ||
Total number of specimens | 505 | 187 | 692 | 3166 | |
Leaves | 359 | 140 | 499 | 2560 | |
Reproductive material | Total number of reproductive material | 146 | 47 | 193 | 606 |
Identified | 89 | 18 | 107 | 338 | |
Unidentified | 57 | 29 | 86 | 268 |