TABLE 1. Measurements of the premaxilla UF 422816 from the Brooksville 2 fossil site. All measurements given in mm. Note: Measurements of the 3rd premaxillary alveolus are not provided here because it is incomplete.
4th Premaxillary Alveolus | Length | 4.28 |
Width | 3.92 | |
5th Premaxillary Alveolus | Length | 2.78 |
Width | 2.63 | |
Premaxillary-Maxillary Suture | Length | 19.74 |
Premaxillary-Premaxillary Suture | Length | 10.91 |
Premaxillary-Nasal Suture | Length | 12.05 |
TABLE 2. Length measurements of the premaxillary-maxillary suture in Alligator. When possible, these were measured on both the left (L) and right (R) sides. In these cases, the value is an average of those two measurements. All A. mississippiensis specimens were from wild populations. Institutional abbreviations: ETMNH-Z, East Tennessee State University Museum of Natural History - Zoology Collection; UF, Vertebrate Paleontology Collection at the University of Florida, Florida Museum of Natural History.
Taxon | Catalog Number | Premax-Max Suture Length (mm) |
Side | Dorsal Skull Length (mm) |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 7217 | 37.72 | L | 271.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 507 | 22.71 | R | 177.46 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 265 | 76.21 | L/R | 506.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 7207 | 41.23 | L/R | 291.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 3036 | 65.35 | L/R | 438.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 7203 | 45.92 | L/R | 315.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 6920 | 53.85 | L/R | 390.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 7208 | 63.50 | L/R | 420.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 7205 | 54.11 | L/R | 375.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 5025 | 22.59 | L/R | 181.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 2957 | 51.53 | L/R | 362.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 509 | 39.51 | L/R | 286.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 3024 | 45.89 | L | 328.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 3366 | 48.28 | L/R | 357.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 487 | 38.88 | L/R | 285.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 17916 | 19.81 | L/R | 163.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 5289 | 21.98 | L/R | 172.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 3371 | 38.93 | L/R | 296.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 10937 | 18.27 | L/R | 149.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 7144 | 30.31 | L/R | 220.00 |
A. mississippiensis | ETMNH-Z 266 | 75.31 | L/R | 480.00 |
Alligator sp. | UF 422816 | 19.74 | R | See Table 3 |
TABLE 3. Dorsal skull lengths used as a proxy for body size in basal Alligator and its ancestors. Alligator mississippiensis with locations specified are from wild populations; specimens with “No Data” may be from either wild or captive populations. ETMNH-Z 10937 and 17916 are known captive specimens. Data are plotted in Figure 7. Institutional Abbreviations: AMNH, American Museum of Natural History, New York, New York, USA; CM, Carnegie Museum of Natural History, Pittsburg, Pennsylvania, USA; ETMNH-Z, East Tennessee State University Museum of Natural History - Zoology Collection, Johnson City, Tennessee, USA; FMNH, Field Museum of Natural History, Chicago, Illinois, USA; MCZ, Museum of Comparative Zoology, Vertebrate Paleontology Collection, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA; SDSM, South Dakota School of Mines Museum of Natural History, Rapid City, South Dakota, USA; SMM P, Science Museum of Minnesota Paleontology Collection, Saint Paul, Minnesota, USA; UF, Vertebrate Paleontology Collection at the University of Florida, Florida Museum of Natural History, Gainesville, Florida, USA; USNM; United States National Museum of Natural History, Vertebrate Paleontology Collection, Washington, D.C., USA; YPM-PU, Yale Peabody Museum and Princeton University Vertebrate Paleontology Collection, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
Taxon | Geologic Age | Skull Length (mm) | Location | Reference | Specimen Number |
Allognathosuchus wartheni | early Eocene | 106 | Wyoming | Miller-Camp, 2016 | YPM-PU 8357 |
Allognathosuchus wartheni | early Eocene | 163 | Wyoming | Miller-Camp, 2016 | YPM-PU 8449 |
Allognathosuchus wartheni | early Eocene | 136 | Wyoming | Miller-Camp, 2016 | MCZ 4367 |
Allognathosuchus polyodon | early Eocene | 172 | Wyoming | Mook, 1961 | AMNH 60491 |
Procaimanoidea kayi | early Eocene | 98 | Wyoming | Mook, 1941 | CM 9600 |
Procaimanoidea utahensis | middle Eocene | 115 | Utah | Gilmore, 1946 | USNM 159962 |
Wannaganosuchus brachymanis | Paleocene | 144 | North Dakota | This Study | SMM P76.28.247 |
Alligator prenasalis | early Oligocene | 198 | South Dakota | This Study | MCZ 1014 |
Alligator prenasalis | Eocene/Oligocene | 215 | South Dakota | This Study | MCZ 1015 |
Alligator prenasalis | Eocene/Oligocene | 223 | South Dakota | Miller-Camp, 2016 | YPM 13799 |
Alligator prenasalis | Eocene/Oligocene | 215 | South Dakota | Miller-Camp, 2016 | YPM 14063 |
Alligator prenasalis | late Eocene | 278 | South Dakota | Miller-Camp, 2016 | YPM 16273 |
Alligator prenasalis | Eocene/Oligocene | 218 | South Dakota | Miller-Camp, 2016 | SDSM 243 |
Alligator olseni | early Miocene | 257 | Florida | This Study | MCZ 1899 |
Alligator olseni | early Miocene | 223 | Florida | This Study | MCZ 1887 [Type] |
Alligator olseni | early Miocene | 299 | Florida | This Study | MCZ 101578 |
Alligator mcgrewi | middle Miocene | 157 | Nebraska | Miller-Camp, 2016 | AMNH 7905 |
Alligator mcgrewi | middle Miocene | 150 | Nebraska | Miller-Camp, 2016 | FMNH P 26242 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 149 | No data | This Study | ETMNH-Z 10937 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 163 | No data | This Study | ETMNH-Z 17916 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 172 | No data | This Study | ETMNH-Z 5289 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 177 | No data | This Study | ETMNH-Z 507 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 181 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 5025 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 220 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 7144 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 271 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 7217 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 285 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 487 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 286 | No data | This Study | ETMNH-Z 509 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 291 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 7207 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 296 | Louisiana | This Study | ETMNH-Z 3371 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 315 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 7203 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 328 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 3024 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 357 | Louisiana | This Study | ETMNH-Z 3366 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 362 | South Carolina | This Study | ETMNH-Z 2957 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 375 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 7205 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 390 | No data | This Study | ETMNH-Z 6920 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 420 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 7208 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 438 | Georgia | This Study | ETMNH-Z 3036 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 480 | Arkansas | This Study | ETMNH-Z 266 |
Alligator mississippiensis | Modern | 506 | Arkansas | This Study | ETMNH-Z 265 |
Alligator sp. | Oligocene | 158.97 | Florida | This Study | UF 422816 |
1Estimated from Mook (1961; figure 1) using the preserved craniomandibular joint to approximate distal end of skull.
2Determined from Plate 11, figure 3 of Gilmore, 1946.
TABLE 4. Statistical support for linear regressions of different premaxillary measurements against dorsal skull length for study set of extant Alligator mississippiensis specimens (n = 22; see Table 2). R2 values are calculated for a ‘best fit’ line. Due to its higher congruence with the data, we selected the premaxillary-maxillary suture length as the best proxy for estimating dorsal skull length.
Premaxillary Measurement | R2 Value |
Overall Width | 0.9125 |
Length of premaxillary-maxillary suture | 0.9917 |
Length of left-right premaxillary suture | 0.7712 |
Width of 4th Premaxillary Alveolus | 0.9221 |
Length of 4th Premaxillary Alveolus | 0.9149 |
Length of 5th Premaxillary Alveolus | 0.9101 |