TABLE 1. Specimen sampling, with basic information on size, colour, and shape.
Taxon | Specimen | Size | Colour | Flattened? | Scanner used |
Crocuta crocuta spelaea (Mammalia) |
ULgPA1806, cranium | 262 mm | Light brown | No | Artec Eva |
Hippurites radiosus (Hippuritida) |
ULgPA3727, complete shells | 158 mm | Beige | No | Artec Eva, Artec Spider |
Ursus spelaeus (Mammalia) |
ULgPA12766, femur | 486 mm | Brown | No | Artec Eva |
Ichthyosaurus sp. (Reptilia) |
ULgPA13413, complete skeleton | 1044 mm | Dark grey | Yes | Artec Eva, Creaform Handyscan |
Pleurosaurus thiollieri (Reptilia) |
ULgPA25056, cast of complete skeleton | 808 mm | Brown | Yes | Artec Eva |
Proterocidaris sp. (Echinoidea) |
ULgPA35400, complete test | 196 mm | Black | Yes | Artec Eva |
Lovenechinus sp. (Echinoidea) |
ULgPA35401, complete test | 174 mm | Black | Moderately | Artec Eva, Creaform Handyscan |
Siphonophyllia cylindrica (Rugosa) |
ULgPA20230303-4, complete skeleton | 136 mm | Light brown | No | Artec Eva |
Caninophyllum patulum (Rugosa) |
ULgPA20230303-5, complete skeleton | 112 mm | Light brown | Mostly no | Artec Eva |
Capra hircus (Mammalia) |
ULgPA20230320-1, cranium | 393 mm | Light beige | No | Artec Eva |
TABLE 2. Effect of glass (new and old) in deviating points compared to the reference mesh. All specimens compared here have been scanned with an Artec Eva.
New glass, points with < 0.5 mm deviation (%) |
New glass, points with < 1 mm deviation (%) |
Old glass, points with < 0.5 mm deviation (%) |
Old glass, points with < 1 mm deviation (%) |
|
ULgPA12766 Ursus spelaeus femur |
99.56 | 99.97 | 75.45 | 94.69 |
ULgPA13413 Ichthyosaurus sp. |
98.71 | 99.95 | NA | NA |
ULgPA1806 Crocuta crocuta spelaea skull |
96.6 | 98.32 | NA | NA |
ULgPA20230303-4 Siphonophyllia cylindrica |
99.16 | 100 | 90.81 | 99.52 |
ULgPA20230303-5 Caninophyllum patulum |
99.82 | 99.95 | 94.29 | 97.45 |
ULgPA20230320-1 Capra hircus skull |
89.29 | 91.74 | 77.17 | 88.38 |
ULgPA25056 Pleurosaurus thiollieri (cast) |
99.39 | 99.92 | 93.55 | 99.91 |
ULgPA35400 Proterocidaris sp. |
98.81 | 99.53 | 96.4 | 100 |
ULgPA35401 Lovenechinus sp. |
94.36 | 98.88 | 93.5 | 99.4 |
ULgPA3727 Hippurites radiosus |
99.76 | 99.96 | 99.6 | 99.98 |
MIN | 89.29 | 91.74 | 75.45 | 88.38 |
MAX | 99.82 | 100 | 99.6 | 100 |
TABLE 3. Raw measurements taken on each mesh generated from specimen ULgPA13413. Laser scans were used as a control and were performed with no glass between scanner and object.
Mesh | Mandible length |
Skull length |
Snout length |
Snout depth |
Orbit length |
Articular to coronoid |
Articular to retroarticular |
Crown diameter |
Crown height |
Laser | 264.304 | 257.67 | 159.27 | 6.77 | 48.08 | 18.48 | 12.46 | 4.51 | 2.53 |
Eva | 266.8 | 262.1 | 164.87 | 5.52 | 47.75 | 20.38 | 15.82 | 4.64 | 2.99 |
Glass horizontal | 265.83 | 261.86 | 162.9 | 7.05 | 46.04 | 20.05 | 15.01 | 4.26 | 3.5 |
TABLE 4. Morphological ratios computed on the raw data (Table 3) for each mesh generated from specimen ULgPA13413.
Mesh | Tooth shape | Absolute crown size |
Relative orbit size |
Relative snout length |
Relative snout depth |
Anterior mechanica adventage |
Opening mechanical adventage |
Laser | 0.56097561 | 2.53 | 0.186595257 | 0.618116195 | 0.042506436 | 0.069919487 | 0.047142684 |
Eva | 0.644396552 | 2.99 | 0.182182373 | 0.62903472 | 0.033480924 | 0.076386807 | 0.059295352 |
Glass horizontal | 0.821596244 | 3.5 | 0.17581914 | 0.622088139 | 0.043278085 | 0.075424143 | 0.056464658 |